Skip to content
Search Canton

Canton, Massachusetts · Saved source text

Article 24 - 1939 Paul Revere Heritage Site Report FINAL 4 13 2017

Town Meeting · Record year 1939 · Record 00a3901f6e21b556ba

Open original municipal record ↗Open interactive reader

Saved text from 128 source pages. Transcription and OCR may contain errors; verify figures and wording against the original. Retrieved 2026-10-15.

Source page 81

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                              April 13, 2017



                                    Table VI-2
        Operating Assumptions in Current Dollars under a Mid-Range Scenario
                       Museum and Cultural Center at PRHS

                                                                 Square Feet (SF)

                                                                        Net Leasable
   Main Building Program                                     Gross Area         Area
    Rolling Mill                                                12,694        8,245
    Barn                                                         6,639        4,796
    Total Building Area                                         19,333       13,041
     Site Area                                                   10.00 acres
   General
    Annual Inflation Rate                                                        2.0%
    Personnel & Benefits Costs Inflation Rate                                    3.0%
    Days Open Per Week                                                              6
    Mid-Range Visitation                                                       25,000
    Museum Visitation                                                          17,000
    Average Visitors Per Day                                                       83
   Admission Fees and Revenue
    Adult Ticket Price                                                          $7.50
    Per Capita Ticket Revenue                                                   $4.54

     Ticket Price & Membership Increase % every other year                       5.0%
     Coupons & Discounts as a % of Per Capita Ticket Rev.                        5.0%
   Corporate Memberships
    Number of Corporate Memberships                                                10
    Average Corporate Membership Fee                                           $1,000
    Average Visits per Corporate Membership                                        50
   Retail
    Retail Sales per Capita                                                     $2.00
    Cost of Goods Sold (COGS) as a % of Gross Sales                               52%
    Outside Sales as a % of Visitor Sales                                         10%




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                           VI-6

Source page 82

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                                   April 13, 2017



                              Table VI-2 (continued)
        Operating Assumptions in Current Dollars under a Mid-Range Scenario
                       Museum and Cultural Center at PRHS

                                                                                Square Feet (SF)
      Vending
       Sales per Capita                                                                         $0.25
       Percent of Gross to Paul Revere Heritage Site                                              20%
      Facility Room Rentals
       Small Events                                                                               100
       Average Attendance, Small Event                                                             25
       Average Revenue, Small Event                                                              $300
        Large Events                                                                               25
        Average Attendance, Large Event                                                           150
        Average Revenue, Large Event                                                           $2,000
                 3/
      Catering
       Total Facility Rentals Attendance                                                        6,250
       Average per Capita Catering Revenue                                                        $64
       Percent of Gross to Paul Revere Heritage Site                                              10%
      Arts and Cultural Programs / Education
       Number of Program Events                                                                        75
       Average Attendance per Event                                                                    10
      Real Estate Rental Income 4/
       Per Square Foot Rent on Net Leasable Area in the Barn                                     $20
       Annual Percent Increase in Rent                                                            5%
       Net Rent based on Leasable Area in the Barn                                           $96,000

      1/ Areas for Cultural Programming and Events are approximations, based on ConsultEcon take
      offs of Leblanc Jones Landscape Architects plan.

      2/ Capacity of outdoor areas based on 20 square feet per person.
      3/ Catering operation are assumed to be operated by a third party operator, including, but not
      limited to, the proposed restaurant in the barn building.
      4/ Mid-range between $18 and $22 per square foot. Assumes a triple net lease where any
      building utilities, maintenance, and taxes are
      Source: ConsultEcon, Inc.




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                                                   VI-7

Source page 83

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                       April 13, 2017



       Retail Sales
Retail store sales are an important revenue source for many museums and visitor
attractions. Visitor retail spending of $2.00 per capita is assumed, including sales at the
museum store. Cost of goods sold is estimated at 52 percent of gross sales. For the
purposes of this analysis, Web and other outside sales are assumed to increase sales 10
percent.


       Food Service
Visitors to attractions such as PRHS typically desire at least a drink and light snack when
they visit which also contributes to the length of stay onsite. The restaurant in the Barn at
PRHS would satisfy this need. As a separate business, the restaurant would not contribute
directly to operations of the museum and cultural center. However, the two operations
would natural partners due to the proximate of their respective facilities, as well as their
interest in taking advantage of the outdoor space for community events, facility rentals, and
programming that may have a catered component. The restaurant, for example, may be a
preferred caterer for events and facility rentals at the museum and cultural center. In
addition, having a shared booking and scheduling function between the restaurant and the
museum and cultural center may contribute to better onsite coordination of activities.
Some degree of coordination, if not shared function, should include the Town’s recreational
programming on PRHS parkland, which has the potential to disrupt both museum and
cultural center and restaurant operations, especially is the events are large and
unanticipated.


       Restaurant Rent
The proposed restaurant in the Barn building would generate an estimated $96,000
annually based on the net leasable area and $20 per square foot. The lease is assumed to
be a “triple net” or NNN lease, where all building operations and maintenance costs are
passed through and paid by the restaurant tenant. For analytic purposes, the Town of
Canton is assumed to pass through the entire restaurant rent to support the operations of
the museum and cultural center at PRHS. Should the Town direct these financial resources


Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                                    VI-8

Source page 84

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                     April 13, 2017



to the museum and cultural center, the financial sustainability of the museum and cultural
center will be better than without this revenue stream.


        Supportive Memberships
Membership programs are often an important revenue source for cultural facilities.
Membership to PRHS may appeal to some due to interest in and affinity for American
history and local arts and culture. Free admission with the purchase of a membership is an
important economic incentive for becoming a member, particularly for residents. Local
corporations and businesses perceive membership more as philanthropy and / or
promotional value and additional exposure and affinity with the Town. This analysis has
an assumed a small number of supportive and corporate memberships as shown in Table
VI-2.


        Arts and Cultural Programs
Included in admissions revenue estimates, arts and cultural programs are assumed to
support admissions overall and encourage repeat visitation for regular educational
programs and special events. Some programs may be included with admissions fees, such
as school programs and teaching carts, tours, an introductory film and historic
anniversaries activities. Program fees would be charged for other programs such as
lectures, demonstrations, performances, storytelling, film series, and so forth. As arts and
cultural programs are further developed, visitation and revenue estimates will need to be
revisited. While program fees may vary depending on the program, for the purposes of this
analysis, an average program fee of $15.00 per visitation is used, as shown by data in Table
VI-2.


        Special Events
Special events include regular and special events and fundraisers sponsored by the
museum and the cultural center. For the purposes of this analysis an average net revenue
of $25.00 per attendee is assumed. Further programming of events at the cultural center
may warrant revisiting special event visitation and revenue assumptions.


Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                                  VI-9

Source page 85

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                       April 13, 2017



       Facility Rentals
Increasingly, museums and cultural facilities are targeting private businesses and groups
for facility rentals for private functions. Rental of the new PRHS for events, along with
catering income from groups and events at the facility, can be an additional revenue source.
In addition to local business, educational, social, and tour group use of the facility, small
meetings, receptions, programs and events for Town departments, non-profit
organizations, business and corporations could also be served at the facility, given its
unique setting. The assumptions regarding facility rentals are based on a facility design
that is assumed to be accommodating to such programs with venues such as exhibition
areas, and classroom and board room space, and outdoor courtyards that are suitable for
events. Further, the facility is expected to be utilized by a wide variety of community
organizations, business and corporations, including the Town departments and area
residents. Estimates of facility rental events and visitation are shown in Table VI-2. This
analysis assumes that facility rentals will be operated by the museum and cultural center.
In addition, it assumes that facility rentals will be adequately promoted via the website and
through Town and other promotional vehicles. Overall, the facility has strong facility rental
potential given its unique architecture, indoor and outdoor setting and art and cultural
programming. For the purposes of this analysis, PRHS is assumed to generate both room
rentals for small and large events as well as catering revenue at 10 percent of the gross
catering revenue, as shown by data in Table VI-2.


Non-Earned Revenue
The museum and cultural center at PRHS will be active in generating substantial non-
earned or contributed revenue support for the facility on an on-going basis. This analysis
estimates the amount of non-earned revenue support for breakeven operations. The
financials presented in this report emphasize (after earned revenue), the non-earned
revenue needed for the museum and cultural center on an annual basis. In many non-profit
cultural facilities, local government, such as the Town of Canton, provide direct, indirect
and in-kind financial support. For example, in the operating expenses estimated in this
analysis, the Town of Canton is assumed to be lease the Rolling Mill to a non-profit museum


Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                                   VI-10

Source page 86

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                       April 13, 2017



and cultural center for $1 per year. It is assumed that the internal capacity to fundraise for
PRHS will be appropriate to the scale of the organization, and that the organization will rely
considerably on non-earned revenues to provide on-going support for the organization.
The organization is expected to engage in on-going fundraising, to establish financial
reserves and endowment, and to secure operating grants and government sector support.
Further, the organization may seek support from corporate sponsors or other sources to
help offset the cost of utilities and maintenance through “in kind” or similar arrangements.

While no assumptions have been made about an endowment in this analysis, an
endowment is often an important component of non-earned revenue for many cultural
facilities. Museums and cultural facilities typically build endowments into the initial
campaign for a start-up project prior to opening the facility. Endowments are important to
providing a predictable source of non-earned revenue for operations, and in assuring other
potential funders of the long-term financial viability of the organization. Because the Town
is presumed to fill much of the needed revenue required for initial development and
ongoing operations, it functions as an endowment of sorts, funding the museum and
cultural center, from its capital and operating funds on an as needed basis. Nonetheless,
the Town may consider establishing separate capital and operating fund vehicles that are
dedicated to sustaining the museum and cultural center operations. This will lead to more
predictable revenue stream that is outside the influence of Town budgeting process that
may be less predictable depending on priorities in Town government that may vary year to
year. Though not included in this operations analysis, the Town can offer the museum and
cultural center in-kind building management services, security and utilities.


Earned Revenue Potential
Based on the project concept as advanced to date, the visitation potential, ticket pricing,
memberships and other revenue assumptions, data in Table VI-3 present a summary of
earned revenue potential in a stable year of operations. The initial years of operation will
benefit from higher visitation levels than is expected in the stable year. The first year estimate
is in current dollars. The actual dollar amounts for Year 1 and subsequent years will depend



Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                                     VI-11

Source page 87

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                                       April 13, 2017



on future rates of inflation, project performance, and the number of years the project takes to
develop before opening.

The stable year earned revenue potential for PRHS is estimated at $394,000, based on the
findings and assumptions of this report.


                                        Table VI-3
                                 Earned Revenue Potential
                             Museum and Cultural Center at PRHS

                                                                                        Percent
                      Sources of Earned Revenue                           Amount        to Total
                      Museum/Community Arts
                       Museum Admissions                                 $77,000          19.5%
                       Memberships                                        28,000           7.1%
                       Retail, Net                                        26,000           6.6%
                       Special Events                                     25,000           6.3%
                       Program Fees                                       11,000           2.8%
                       Corporate Memberships                              10,000           2.5%
                       Subtotal                                        $177,000           44.9%

                      Facility Rental
                       Restaurant Rent 1/                                $96,000          24.4%
                       Facility Rentals                                   80,000          20.3%
                       Catering, Net                                      40,000          10.2%
                       Vending                                              1,000          0.3%
                       Subtotal                                        $217,000           55.1%

                      Total Earned Revenue Potential                   $394,000         100.0%

                      Note: Sources rounded to nearest $1,000.
                      1/ Assumes that the Town of Canton passes through the entire gross
                      revenue to the museum and Cultural Center at the PRHS. Restaurant rent
                      is assumed at $20 per square foot of the net leasable area and a triple net
                      lease, where all building operations and maintenance costs are paid by the
                      restaurant tenant.
                      Source: ConsultEcon, Inc.




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                                                  VI-12

Source page 88

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                          April 13, 2017



Operating Expense Profile
Museums and cultural facilities such as PRHS have high fixed costs. These fixed costs include
utilities, insurance, personnel, exhibits and collections care, basic marketing, and
maintenance. However, there is some variability in expenses for visitor services, changing
exhibits, education programs, marketing and so forth based on visitation levels and hours of
operation per week. In this analysis, the expense profile was developed to reflect the site,
building and program plans supplied by the Town, the developer and their consultants, and
the experience of other projects of this type, adjusted for local conditions. The operating
performance of regional heritage attractions was reviewed as well as that of other case
studies. Inputs to the operating expenses analyses include the experience of similar facilities
nationally and the “metrics” of the new facility – its size, program, type of exhibits, visitation
potential and locational factors. Increasingly detailed operating expense plans should be
developed in subsequent planning during the construction phases and pre-opening of the
project. The expenses reflect a tightly operated project with a “bottom line” orientation.
These profiles do not reflect the capitalized reinvestment in PRHS that will be necessary
over time for the physical structure. If higher revenues than those projected are attained,
additional reinvestment in programs and exhibits could be possible. Following are
discussions of some of the major expense categories for the project.


       Personnel Expenses
Data in Table VI-4 provide illustrative staffing schedules for PRHS based on facility size and
program, projected visitation patterns, and operating scenario. Compensation levels for the
project were developed based on the experience of similar not-for-profit organizations,
museum industry surveys, and occupational salary data from the U.S. Bureau of Labor
Statistics. These salary levels are for comparative and analytical purposes only and are not
meant to be used to set the compensation levels for any given individual. A fringe rate for
taxes and benefits of approximately 25 percent is used in this analysis. The staffing profile
prepared for this analysis is appropriate for a facility of this size and a mid-range visitation
scenario. The staffing profile assumes that the organization will be very active in educational




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                                     VI-13

Source page 89

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                                     April 13, 2017



programming both on and off site, with facility rentals and events, as well as collaborations
with other community organizations and partners throughout the region, state and nation.

The staff required to operate PRHS is 6.2 full time equivalent (FTE) positions. It is assumed
that full and part time staff positions will be supplemented by an hourly workers and
volunteers who will have duties associated with education, facility/collections care, special
events, visitor services and other important functions. As funding and operating experience
allow, additional staff positions could enrich the offerings and operations of PRHS. The total
payroll for the project, based on this staffing profile, is estimated to be $427,000 inclusive of
overhead and benefits.1 Personnel direct salary and fringe benefit costs are approximately 66
percent of total operating expenses, which is within the norms of the cultural industry.




1 The salary level assumptions are based on U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics occupational data for Southeastern

Massachusetts, and typical cultural industry pay scales. If THE TOWN wage and benefit scales are used,
personnel costs may vary from those shown in this report.



Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                                                  VI-14

Source page 90

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                                                                                                            April 13, 2017



                                                      Table VI-4
                        Illustrative Personnel Positions and Personnel Costs by Department
                                        Museum and Cultural Center at PRHS

                                                              Annual                  Number of Number of              Total Hours    Total
                                                              Salaries   Hourly        Full Time Part Time              for Hourly   Salary
     Position                                                  (FTE)     Salaries      Positions Positions               Workers     Budget     Responsibilities
     Administration
     Executive Director                                       $100,000                      1                                        $100,000 Day to day management, fundraising

      Administrative Assistant/Bookkeeper                      $50,000                                      1                         $25,000 Reception, bookkeeping, office
                                                                                                                                              management

     Marketing, Membership,
     Facility Rentals and Events
      Director of Public Outreach                              $55,000                      1                                         $55,000 Membership program, facility rental and
                                                                                                                                              special events, volunteer coordination
                                       1/
      Facility Rentals Attendants                                           $17.50                                            500      $8,750 Host and guest relations

     Education, Programs, Exhibits
      Director of Visitor Experience                           $70,000                      1                                         $70,000 Exhibits, curatorial and collections
                                                                                                                                              management, and educational program
                                                                                                                                              development
      Educators                                                             $20.00                                            300      $6,000 Deliver education programs, tours
     Visitor Services / Retail / Admissions
      Visitor Services / Retail Manager                        $40,000                      1                                         $40,000 Oversight of admissions, retail, reception,
                                                                                                                                              and buying merchandise
      Cashiers - Admissions/Retail                                          $15.00                                        2,500       $37,500 Guest services, reception, retail store

     Facility Operations
      Maintenance                                            Outside Contract - see expenses                                               NA
      Custodial                                              Outside Contract - see expenses                                               NA
      Grounds (Parklands and Courtyards)                     Town of Canton                                                                NA

     Total                                                                                  4               1             3,300      $342,250
     Taxes, Fringe & Benefits as a percent of
     Total Salaries 2/                                               @ 24.8%                                                          $85,015
     Total Salaries, Taxes, Fringe & Benefits                                                                                        $427,265
                                                        3/
     Total Full Time Equivalent (FTE) Positions                                                                                           6.2

1/
     Large events only. Based on an average of 10 hours per event and an average of 2 attendants per event.
2/
     Weighted average assuming that Taxes, Fringe and Benefits are 28% of full time salaries and 14% of part time salaries.
3/
     Part Time Employees Calculated at 50% FTE and Total Hours of Hourly Workers divided by 2,000 hours.
     Source: ConsultEcon, Inc.




                 Non-Personnel Operating Expenses
Data in Table VI-5 provide a summary of operating expense estimates for a stable year of
operations in current dollars. Following is a summary of expense categories for the project.

                 Administrative Costs
Administrative costs include costs associated with phone and internet, equipment rental and
lease, travel and professional development, entertainment, and dues and subscriptions,
professional services, supplies and materials and development and fundraising costs.



Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                                                                                                                               VI-15

Source page 91

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                       April 13, 2017



Professional services include: consulting fees, accounting and payroll, tax preparation and
auditing, legal fees, consulting contracts for information technology, etc. Supplies include
consumable items such office supplies, custodial supplies, paper products and other materials.
It should be noted that this category does not include merchandise in the store and gift shop,
which is netted out of this operations analysis.

       Occupancy
This expense category includes rent utilities, repairs and maintenance, custodial, security, and
insurance. As noted, it is assumed that the Town of Canton charges $1 in annual rent.
Although not reflected in this analysis, the Town may also absorb other occupancy costs to
improve the organization’s financial sustainability by delivering building management
services to the museum and cultural center.


       Marketing and Programs
Marketing encompasses the cost of advertising, promotion, printing and publications include
the design, production and distribution expenses for web, television, radio, newspaper,
posters, brochures and rack cards and other printed matter including office stationary and
letterhead, press release packages, educational kits, tour guides and others. It is assumed that
PRHS will prepare a marketing plan appropriate for the facility, the visitation potential and
the marketing channels in the Canton and Boston regional markets. In addition to the
marketing budget, it is expected that PRHS will receive much free publicity by the Town, as
well as local media stations and sources initially and over time. PRHS will work with state and
local tourism promotion channels as well as other local museums, visitor attractions, artists,
arts, cultural and community organizations on collaborative marketing initiatives. Further, it
is anticipated that PRHS will also seek corporate underwriting for additional advertising,
promotions, sponsorships and memberships.

Costs associated with the production of onsite education programs sponsored by PRHS are
assumed at $2 per school group attendee. While not included in this operations analysis, the
costs of education programs can be supported by sponsorships, gifts, grants and other




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                                    VI-16

Source page 92

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                      April 13, 2017



revenues that support education, arts and culture. In addition, other Town departments, arts,
cultural, and community partners may use the facility for events and programs. The costs of
externally produced programs would largely be borne by the external partner and are
therefore assumed to be revenue neutral to the museum and cultural center operations, with
revenues/chargebacks to partners cover the cost of hosting the event.

        Exhibits
Exhibit costs include the cost of changing exhibits, collections care/storage, and an allowance
for ongoing exhibit reinvestment due to wear and tear and minor replacements. Major
replacements of exhibits would occur infrequently and require capital fundraising.


        Outdoor Areas
Outdoor area costs are for operations and maintenance are assumed to be borne by the Town
of Canton through its operation and maintenance of PRHS park and recreation facilities.


        Other
Other expenses include miscellaneous expenses such as postage, shipping, and other staff and
administrative costs.

        Capital Reserves
A capital reserves fund is used to cover major non-recurring expenses for mechanical,
electrical and plumbing repairs and maintenance contracts. These costs are expected to be
less during the early years of operation due to new construction and extended warranty
periods. Capital reserves may also contribute to future changing programs and exhibits,
collection care, minor building improvements and replacement of large equipment under
heavy use such as HVAC units. This reserve can also double as an operating expense
contingency fund in emergencies. Contributions to this fund are usually made from surplus
net operating income, but can also be funded through fundraising. An annual budget of
approximately 5 percent of the subtotal of operating expenses for capital reserves is included
in this analysis.




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                                 VI-17

Source page 93

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                       April 13, 2017



Total Operating Expenses
Estimated operating expenses are $670,000 in a stable year of operations in current dollar
value. The expense factors used in this analysis conform to cultural industry norms for
facilities of this size and scale. As design, program, leasing and business plans advance,
operating expense estimates and factor assumptions will need to be re-evaluated and updated
accordingly.




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                                    VI-18

Source page 94

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                                                                                            April 13, 2017



                                     Table VI-5
        Operating Expense Estimates in a Stable Year in 2016 Value of the Dollar
                            Under a Mid-Range Scenario
                        Museum and Cultural Center at PRHS
          Project Parameters
          Gross Square Footage                                                      12,694         Rolling Mill Only
          Stable Year Annual Visitation                                             25,000
          School Group Visitation                                                    1,500
          Employees (FTEs)                                                              6.2                    See Personnel Schedule

                                                                                Annual
          Detailed Budgetary Analysis                                           Amount             Expense Factors 1/                    Percent of Total

          Personnel Costs
           Salaries (FTE, PTE)                                                   $342,250          See Personnel Schedule                             51.1%
           Overhead and Benefits                                                   85,015          See Personnel Schedule                             12.7%
           Interns                                                                 15,000          1,000 hrs @ $15/hr.                                 2.2%
          Administrative Costs
           Telecommunications (Phone and Internet)                                    6,000 @          $500 per Month                                  0.9%
           Equipment Rental/Lease                                                     4,000                 budget                                     0.6%

           Travel/Professional Development/Entertainment                              4,920    @       $800 per FTE                                    0.7%
           Dues & Subscriptions & Prof. Affiliations                                  2,153    @       $350 per FTE                                    0.3%
           Professional Services                                                      9,600    @       $800 per Month                                  1.4%
           Supplies & Materials                                                       2,400    @       $200 per Month                                  0.4%
           Development & Fundraising Costs                                            5,000                 budget                                     0.7%
          Occupancy Costs
           Rent                                                                          1     @             assumed to Town                           0.0%
           Insurance                                                                12,694     @       $1.00 per GSF                                   1.9%
           Utilities (Water/sewer, gas, electric)                                   25,388     @       $2.00 per GSF                                   3.8%
           Repairs and Maintenance                                                  25,388     @       $2.00 per GSF                                   3.8%
           Custodial                                                                12,694     @       $1.00 per GSF
           Security                                                                      0                   assumes Town police                       0.0%
                                                                                                             sufficient
          Marketing and Programs Costs
           Advertising and Promotion                                               25,000      @       $1.00 per Attendee                              3.7%
           Printing, Publications and Postage                                       6,250      @       $0.25 per Attendee                              0.9%
           School Programs                                                          3,000      @       $2.00 per School Attendee                       0.4%
           Changing Exhibits                                                       20,000                    budget                                    3.0%
           Exhibit Reinvestment                                                     8,750      @       $0.35 per Attendee                              1.3%
           Special Events                                                          10,000                    budget
          Other Operating Expenses                                                 12,310      @        2.0% of other expenses                         1.8%
          Subtotal Operating Expenses                                            $637,813                                                             95.2%
          Capital Reserves                                                         $31,891 @            5.0% of subtotal                               4.8%

          Total Operating Expenses                                               $669,703                                                           100.0%
          Rounded to nearest $1,000                                              $670,000
          Selected Operating Metrics
           Expenses per Gross Square Feet                                           $52.76
           Expenses per Attendee                                                    $26.79
           Expenses per FTE                                                      $108,895

          TBD = To Be Determined
          1/ Operating factors are based on industry standards.
          2/ Costs are adjusted by 65% due to allocation of space to Cultural Center and non-Cultural Center operations (i.e. Cultural Services offices and
          collections/storage), as shown in Table II-2. occupancy and maintenance costs of the facility would be higher than amounts shown here.
          Source: ConsultEcon, Inc.




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                                                                                                       VI-19

Source page 95

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                        April 13, 2017



Non-Earned Revenue Required for Breakeven Operations
Data in Table VI-6 show the non-earned revenue requirement for breakeven operations at
PRHS in a stable year of operations in the current value of the dollar. PRHS has capacity to
generate earned revenue from a variety of sources, including admissions, retail, and facility
rentals. At the same time, operating a complex and labor-intensive operation such as PRHS
requires considerable operating expenses. As is typical of projects of this type, it is
anticipated that PRHS will require substantial on-going annual non-earned or contributed
revenue support for operations. Based on the earned revenue potential and operating
expense estimates for the project, this analysis indicates that PRHS will require $276,000 on
an annual basis to sustain operations as earned revenues represent 59 percent of total needed
revenues to support operations in a stable year.

Contributed revenues should be targeted at levels higher than contained herein, as these will
allow more robust levels of service provision, will create revenues to cover any shortfalls in
earned revenue that may occur in certain time periods, and could contribute to increasing the
financial reserves and endowment. With the efforts of a well-established board of directors
and advisors, an active development and fundraising program, this should be an attainable
goal. Establishing an endowment before project opening will contribute to the long-term
sustainability of the project.




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                                   VI-20

Source page 96

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                                                      April 13, 2017



                                  Table VI-6
    Summary of Revenues and Expenses in a Stable Year in 2016 Value of the Dollar
                          Under a Mid-Range Scenario
                      Museum and Cultural Center at PRHS

                                                                                                          Percent to
                                                                                   Stable Year of              Total
                                                                                     Operations,          Operating
                                                                                    2017 Dollars           Expenses

          Mid-Range Visitation                                                             25,000

          Earned Revenue
           Museum / Community Art Center                                                $177,000               26.4%
           Facility Rentals                                                              217,000               32.4%
           Total Earned Revenue                                                         $394,000               58.8%

          Operating Expenses                                                            $670,000             100.0%
          Net Income Before Non-Earned Revenues                                        ($276,000)             -41.2%

          Non-Earned Revenue Requirement 1/                                             $276,000               41.2%

          Net Income After Non-Earned Revenue Requirement                                       $0              0.0%

          Earned Revenue as a Percent of Operating Expenses                                   59%


          1/ The difference between the estimated operating expenses and the earned revenue potential. Potential
          sources of contributed, non-earned revenue include government and private gifts, grants, in-kind and other
          donations, and proceeds from investments and interest.
          Source: ConsultEcon, Inc.




Multi-Year Operating Performance
The operations analysis presented so far has focused on a stable year of operations under a
mid-range visitation scenario to highlight the operating potential possible for the museum
and cultural center at PRHS. The operations of the facility will ultimately depend on the
market response to the project and the extent of programs and operations established by the
facility operator, the tenant the Town identifies for the project. In the early years after to
facility opening, when visitation is higher than in a stable year, and awareness of PRHS is
heightened, ticket and other visitation driven revenue (e.g. retail) is likely to be higher than in
later years. During a five-year period, there will be some variability in operating performance
based on the years’ individual circumstances (general economic climate, travel and weather



Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                                                                 VI-21

Source page 97

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                                                                               April 13, 2017



patterns, etc.), with higher levels of non-earned revenue support allowing higher levels of
cash flow and/or enhanced operations. Analysis of the five-year operations for the project,
including visitation, earned revenue and operating expenses, are reflected by data in
Appendix Table B-1 through Appendix Table B-3. Data in Table VI-7 show the five-year
summary of revenue and expenses, along with the annual requirement for non-earned
revenue support.


                                                Table VI-7
                           5-Year Net Income Summary under a Mid-Range Scenario
                                    Museum and Cultural Center at PRHS

                                                                                                               Stabilized
 Mid Range Scenario                                                          YEAR 1             YEAR 2            YEAR 3             YEAR 4             YEAR 5
 ATTENDANCE                                                                   28,750            27,500             25,000            25,250             25,500

 Earned Revenue
  Museum / Community Art Center                                           $203,000          $197,000           $192,000           $195,000          $206,000
  Facility Rentals                                                         206,000           210,000            214,000            219,000           223,000
  Total Earned Revenue 1/                                                 $409,000          $407,000           $406,000           $414,000          $429,000

 Operating Expenses                                                       $649,000          $656,000           $659,000           $678,000          $697,000
 Net Income Before Non-Earned Revenues                                   ($240,000)         ($249,000)        ($253,000)         ($264,000)        ($268,000)
 Non-Earned Revenue Requirement 1/                                        $240,000          $249,000           $253,000           $264,000          $268,000

 Net Income After Non-Earned Revenue Requirement                                  $0                $0                 $0                 $0                 $0

 Earned Revenue as a Percent of Operating Expenses                            63.0%              62.0%             61.6%              61.1%             61.5%

 Note: Year 1 shown in 2017 dollars.
 1/ Does not equal total shown in Appendix Table B-2, Five-Year Earned Revenue Potential under a Mid Range Visitation Scenario due to rounding.
 2/ The difference between the estimated operating expenses and the earned revenue potential. Potential sources of contributed, non-earned revenue include
 government and private gifts, grants, in-kind and other donations, and proceeds from investments and interest.
 Source: ConsultEcon, Inc.




Pre-Opening Operations
This report evaluates the operating potential of the museum and cultural center at PRHS after
project opening. In addition to funds for construction and development, the project’s museum
operations will need to be ramped up over a period before occupancy. Before opening there
will be operating costs such as program development, staff training, fundraising, marketing,
cleaning, etc. The amount of these costs will depend on when various personnel are hired
and how the pre-opening period is organized and implemented. These operations are



Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                                                                                               VI-22

Source page 98

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                    April 13, 2017



typically capitalized as a part of the overall development plan. These pre-opening costs are
not included in this analysis which focuses on ongoing operations of the museum and
cultural center at PRHS after project opening.




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                               VI-23

Source page 99

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                    April 13, 2017



                                         APPENDIX A
                                        CASE STUDIES


This appendix includes several case studies of museum developments that may provide
operating insight to the business plan for the Paul Revere Heritage Site. They were selected
based on one or more of the following criteria, including:
   ♦ Location in the Greater Boston Area;
   ♦ Location in a suburban context;
   ♦ Facility square footage of approximately 10,000 square feet; and,
   ♦ Interpretive themes surrounding industrial history, city history, or historic
       personalities.


Case studies include:
   ♦ Metropolitan Waterworks Museum – Boston, MA (Table A-1)
   ♦ Dedham Historical Society – Dedham, MA (Table A-2)
   ♦ Eleanor Cabot Bradley Estate – Canton, MA (Table A-3)
   ♦ The Park City Museum – Park City, UT (Table A-4)
   ♦ Museum of Durham History – Durham, NC (Table A-5)


Additional museums and organizations that were considered for analysis in this section
included:
   ♦ American Museum of Tort Law, Winsted, CT: Opened in early fall of 2015, this
     museum provides an overview of the history of Tort Law in the United States and a
     selection of significant cases. Its suburban location between Boston and New York
     makes it fairly accessible to either city, though it is not in an urban location.




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                                  A-1

Source page 100

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                April 13, 2017



                                         Figure A-1
                                American Museum of Tort Law
                                        Winsted, CT




                     Source: UMass Dartmouth School of Law

   ♦ Charles River Museum of Industry & Innovation, Waltham, MA: This museum
     features a collection of historic industrial equipment and interpretation of New
     England industry and innovation history. The museum is located in the former
     Boston Manufacturing Company – Francis Cabot Lowell’s first manufacturing mill.
     The organization has leveraged its location and large, unique facility as a popular
     venue for programs, concerts, and private events. An estimated 13,000 people visit
     the museum annually.


                                      Figure A-2
                     Charles River Museum of Industry & Innovation
                                     Waltham, MA




                     Source: BillDamon.com




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                              A-2

Source page 101

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                April 13, 2017



   ♦ Edison and Ford Winter Estates, Fort Myers, FL: 20 acres of botanical gardens
     and 9 historic buildings make up the Edison Ford Museum. Facilities include the
     historic homes, as well as the historic botanical laboratory and the Edison Ford
     Museum. Interpretation includes the significance of botanical and other research
     conducted by Edison and Ford, as well as the friendship between the two inventors.
     The museum welcomes an estimated 250,000 visitors annually.


                                          Figure A-3
                                Edison and Ford Winter Estates
                                        Fort Myers, FL




                     Source: Wikimedia user Euku


   ♦ Eli Whitney Museum and Workshop, Hamden, CT: This museum was established
     in 1979 as a not-for-profit historic and educational organization. The Museum
     preserves the site on which Whitney constructed the first American factory in 1798.
     The Eli Whitney Museum and Workshop is an experimental learning workshop for
     students, teachers, and families. The organization collects, interprets, and teaches
     experimentation as the root of design and invention. The museum welcomes an
     estimated 48,000 visitors annually in its location just north of New Haven, CT.




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                              A-3

Source page 102

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                April 13, 2017



                                         Figure A-4
                            Eli Whitney Museum and Workshop
                                        Hamden, CT




                     Source: eliwhitney.org


   ♦ Garst Museum and National Annie Oakley Center, Greenville, OH: Located in the
     Historic Garst House, a former inn, the museum features over 300,000 artifacts in its
     35,000 SF of exhibit space within six major and two minor venues. Exhibit
     highlights include the National Annie Oakley Center, and information about the
     Treaty of Greeneville, and other moments of historical significance. The museum
     achieves attendance of about 20,000 annually.


                                     Figure A-5
                    Garst Museum and National Annie Oakley Center
                                   Greenville, OH




                     Source: Wikipedia User Nyttend




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                              A-4

Source page 103

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                    April 13, 2017



   ♦ Highfield Hall & Gardens, Falmouth, MA: The mission of Highfield Hall & Gardens
     is to preserve Cape Cod’s preeminent historic estate by offering an engaging
     environment to experience the arts, explore nature, and appreciate history. The
     building was first built in 1878, and restored in the late 1990s to serve the
     community as a museum, as well as a program and event space. Upstairs space is
     leased to local businesses. The organization celebrated 10 years of being open to
     the public in 2016.


                                          Figure A-6
                                   Highfield Hall & Gardens
                                        Falmouth, MA




                     Source: Highfield Hall and Gardens


   ♦ Slater Mill, Pawtucket, RI: Slater Mill was the first successful cotton-spinning
     factory in the United States, leveraging its riverfront location to engineer an efficient
     water-powered mill when it was built in 1793. It is recognized as the “Birthplace of
     the American Industrial Revolution.” Preserved by the Old Slater Mill Association,
     the campus is now designated as a National Historic Landmark District, featuring
     three historic structures, a gift shop, an exhibition gallery space, the Jencks
     Education Conference Center and Rental Hall, and the Hodgson Rotary Park.
     Previously, there was a café located onsite. The mill welcomes an estimated 25,000
     visitors annually.




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                                  A-5

Source page 104

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                              April 13, 2017



                                            Figure A-7
                                            Slater Mill
                                           Pawtucket, RI




                     Source: Slater Mill




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                            A-6

Source page 105

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                           April 13, 2017



                                        Table A-1
                            Metropolitan Waterworks Museum
                                       Boston, MA
 Name and Location         Metropolitan Waterworks Museum, Boston, MA
 Attendance (Total)        Between 8,000 and 10,000 Annually
 Attendance by Type        General attendance includes school groups, programs, etc. School
 • General Admission       groups include at least 500 annually from Brookline Public Schools, and
 • School Groups           some other occasional groups.
 • Programs
 • Facility Rentals        Facility rental attendance makes up 7,000 visits annually.
 • Other Events
 Number of Facility        40 to 50 per year, though the organization is feeling mission-drift from
 Rentals                   facility rentals. They have become a popular and affordable use for the
                           museum, and, while the revenue generation is nice, the operations are
                           suffering from having weddings almost every weekend.
 Fees for:                 No admission fee, but donations are accepted.
 • General Admission
 • School Groups
 • Programs
 • Facility Rentals
 • Other Events

 Number of Staff           3 Full Time (Executive Director, Operations Director, and Director of
                           Events); 2 Part Time (Education and Development); 2 Part Time
                           Weekend Mangers; Rotating cast of interns.
 Number of Volunteers      Currently 20, though there is capacity for more. Most volunteers are
                           former/professional engineers, who have a lot of background
                           appreciation for hardware in the museum. Volunteers run tours, staff
                           the welcome desk, answer the phone… the organization relies heavily
                           on volunteers.
 Total Revenue             Between $350,000 and $375,000 annually.
                           Also supported by a $1.2 million endowment.
 Revenue from:             Revenue streams include:
 • Admissions              • Condo Fees (112 residents pay annual fee to museum, though not
 • Programs                    always painlessly)
 • Facility Rentals        • Condo Sales (museum receives 1-3 percent on any given condo
 • Memberships                 sale, which, on a $3 million condo, isn’t bad!)
                           • Annual Appeal ($10-12,000)
                           • General donations ($10,000)
                           • Rentals ($40-50,000)
                           • Gift shop (negligible)
                           • Grants (MCC, other…)
 Total Expenses            Organization consistently breaks even – about $350-375,000.
 Facility Size             Somewhere between 20,000 and 22,000 SF. The “party line” is 22,000,
                           and that is what the website says.




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                                         A-7

Source page 106

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                               April 13, 2017



                                     Table A-1 (continued)
                                Metropolitan Waterworks Museum
                                           Boston, MA
 Success Factors /             •   Accessibility close to T, but still somewhat off the beaten path.
 Lessons Learned               •   Need more signage, visibility.
                               •   Limited parking, need more parking.
                               •   Exhibits static and considering reinvesting in them to make them
                                   more relevant to current topics in water access, especially
                                   advocacy for water access, both in U.S. and globally.
                               •   Capital projects and maintenance take a lot of time in adaptive
                                   reuse.
                               •   Facility rentals take up a lot of time, require closure of the
                                   museum on weekends for general admission audience
                               •   Staff and leadership turnover disruptive to setting organizational
                                   goals.
                               •   Early mission statement did not highlight educational value of
                                   interpretive elements. Recent developments have shifted focus of
                                   museum.
Source: Waterworksmuseum.org; Interview with Eric Peterson, Director of Operations, 1/27/2017.


                                           Figure A-8
                                Metropolitan Waterworks Museum
                                           Boston, MA




Source: Waterworks Museum




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                                             A-8

Source page 107

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                        April 13, 2017



                                          Figure A-9
                           Metropolitan Waterworks Museum Interior
                                         Boston, MA




Source: the Garden Club of Back Bay




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                      A-9

Source page 108

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                         April 13, 2017



                                       Table A-2
                                 Dedham Historical Society
                                      Dedham, MA
 Name and Location         Dedham Historical Society, Dedham, MA

 Attendance (Total)        Est. 1,650
 Attendance by Type        General:         200
                           School:          250
                           Programs:        400
                           Facility Rental: Not Applicable
                           Other:           800 (Includes off site attendance, participants in
                                            Dedham’s annual Flag Day Parade, those who stop at a
                                            table at the weekly summer farmer’s market, and
                                            fundraising events off site)
 Number of Facility        Not Applicable
 Rentals
 Fees for:
 • General Admission       $2 adults;$1 children
 • School Groups           $1 per child; teachers free
 • Programs                Varies $5 - $25
 • Facility Rentals        Not Applicable
                           Fundraising events vary $50 - $100 per ticket
 • Other Events
 Number of Staff           1 FT; 3 PT; 2 contractors

 Number of Volunteers      5 weekly; 25 special committees; 12 board
 Total Expenses            Est. $140,000
 Total Revenue             Est. earned revenue $105,000
                           Earned revenues fall short of expenses, but difference between revenue
                           and expenses is made up of the endowment drawdown.
 Revenue from:
                           Annual appeal          45%
                           Membership             23%
                           Museum shop            5%
                           Endowment drawdown 5%.
                           Research fees          2%
                           General contributions 2%
                           Admissions:            1%
                           Programs:              Less than 1%
                           Other sources of income include: event sponsorships, local operating
                           grants (from organizations like the Rotary Club), fundraising events,
                           and event and program sponsorships.
 Facility Size             4,700 sq. ft.




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                                      A-10

Source page 109

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                             April 13, 2017



                                            Table A-2
                                      Dedham Historical Society
                                           Dedham, MA
 Success Factors /             •    Dedham Town history reaches back to the Dedham Grant, which
 Lessons Learned                    reaches from Bellingham in the South to Natick and Wellesley in the
                                    north – interpretation of more than just the town’s history.
                               •    Dedham Historical Society owns the name and original trademark
                                    of Dedham Pottery, making and selling reproductions of the
                                    products.
                               •    Operations include both museum and research library with
                                    extensive archival collections, deemphasizing visitor services and
                                    interpretation, and focusing on preservation of collections.
                               •    The Dedham Historical Society building was built specifically for
                                    the organization in 1887-1888 and the organization has no
                                    mortgage or occupancy cost associated with the building.
Source: Dedham Historical Society

                                           Figure A-10
                                      Dedham Historical Society
                                           Dedham, MA




        Source: Trip Advisor




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                                          A-11

Source page 110

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                       April 13, 2017



                                     Figure A-11
                     Dedham Historical Society, Program Attendees
                                    Dedham, MA




                     Source: Dedham Historical Society




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                   A-12

Source page 111

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                          April 13, 2017



                                         Table A-3
                                Eleanor Cabot Bradley Estate
                                        Canton, MA
 Name and Location         Eleanor Cabot Bradley Estate, Trustees of Reservations, Canton, MA

 Attendance (Total)        Estimate of 19,500 in 2016 (estimate based on car counter calibrated to
                           reflect visitors)

 Attendance by Type        Estimated 19,500 visitors to the property.
 • General Admission       2,500 estimated to have participate in public programs, including house
 • School Groups           tours.
 • Programs                There is not currently a school / education program on site, so visits by
 • Facility Rentals        school groups are not relevant to this site.
 • Other Events            Facility rentals make up about 2,000 site visits annually (most
                           weddings are Friday nights.
 Number of Facility        Average of 22 event rentals. Most weddings are June-October.
 Rentals
 Fees for:
 • General Admission       Free Admission
 • School Groups           Not Applicable
 • Programs                House tours, $5.00; Other programs average $10.00
 • Facility Rentals        Range depending on event size, but typically average $2,000 to $5,000.
 • Other Events            Not Applicable
 Number of Staff           One Trustees staff member is designated as engagement coordinator
                           for the Bradley Estate. Other on-site staff are associated with different
                           departments and regions of the Trustees organization. 2 Stewardship
                           staff manage the Southeast Gardens region, which has 7 sites. One
                           horticulturalist manages gardens at 2 other properties.
 Number of Volunteers      The Bradley Estate benefitted from 1,200 hours of volunteer service
                           between both public programming and gardening. It is one of the more
                           active volunteer sites because of the growing programming component,
                           the gardening opportunities, and nature of the community in which it is
                           located.
 Total Expenses            Not Available

 Total Revenue             Not Available

 Revenue from:             Not Available
 • Admissions
 • Programs
 • Facility Rentals
 • Memberships
 Facility Size             House of 8,448 SF was previously used as offices for the Trustees, but
                           was left vacant for several years. In summer of 2016, the house was
                           opened for tours, but does not have an extensive collection or active
                           programming. Focus is on architecture.




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                                       A-13

Source page 112

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                                   April 13, 2017



                                        Table A-3 (continued)
                                     Eleanor Cabot Bradley Estate
                                             Canton, MA
 Success Factors /              •   House was first opened to the public in August of 2016 and
 Lessons Learned                    programming is still in development. The house does not hold an
                                    historic collection, so the focus of programming inside is on
                                    architecture and the family history.
                                •   Public engagement with public garden sites is active. The
                                    community is excited about opportunities to engage with activities
                                    and volunteer opportunities on site, more so than on nature
                                    preserve sites with trail networks.
                                •   The estate is one of 117 sites in Massachusetts managed by the
                                    Trustees of Reservations. The organization sorts and staffs these
                                    sites based on region and site programming opportunities (public
                                    gardens, trails, historic house museums, etc.) Not all sites are open
                                    to the public. Distributing staff across sites is key to managing
                                    operations at otherwise low-visitation sites.
                                •   Trustees recently underwent reorganization process that balances
                                    general management at individual sites / regional groupings of
                                    sites with specialized services from central office, including
                                    curatorial and horticultural services. This allows the organization
                                    to be more active with programming on each site.
                                •   Bradley has become a focus site for 2017, meaning that the
                                    operations and programs and executive teams have advised the
                                    manager at Bradley to prioritize activation of the site for visitors, in
                                    terms of both property significance and the “spirit of place.”
                                •   Site has limited accessibility because of its location on Washington
                                    Street. Trustees try to offer basic amenities at each site,
                                    acknowledging necessity of ease of access, parking, restrooms, and
                                    basic food options at each site as appropriate.
                                •   Trustees are very much interested in innovative partnerships and
                                    the idea that “rising tides lift all ships.” Potential of partnership
                                    between Bradley Estate and Paul Revere Heritage Site may be of
                                    interest to the organization.
Source: TheTrustees.org; Interview with Ross Moran, Regional Property Manager for Southeast Gardens and
South Coast Trustees Sites (January 31, 2017); Interview with Cindy Brockway, Program Director for Cultural
Resources for The Trustees of Reservations (February 1, 2017)




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                                                A-14

Source page 113

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                             April 13, 2017



                                          Figure A-12
                          Eleanor Cabot Bradley Estate – Front of House
                                          Canton, MA




Source: TheTrustees.org


                                         Figure A-13
                            Eleanor Cabot Bradley Estate – Wedding
                                          Canton, MA




Source: TheTrustees.org




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                         A-15

Source page 114

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                       April 13, 2017



                                      Figure A-14
                          Eleanor Cabot Bradley Estate – Interior
                                       Canton, MA




Source: TheTrustees.org




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                   A-16

Source page 115

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                           April 13, 2017



                                          Table A-4
                                      Park City Museum
                                        Park City, UT
 Name and Location         Park City Museum, Park City, Utah
 Attendance (Total)        An estimated 125,000 people enter the front doors of the museum
                           annually. Typically between 25 and 30 percent of them stay and pay
                           the admission price.
 Attendance by Type        • Programs and Groups are counted on top of general attendance.
                           • About 1,800 to 2,000 children in school groups attend the
                               museum annually.
                           • There are some member-only events, including a monthly hiking
                               trip that attracts 20-40 attendees.
                           • Walking tours are open to the public daily.
                           • Annual historic house tour (which includes admission into
                               people’s houses) attracts about 400 people annually.
 Number of Facility        Minimal facility rentals. When it does happen, it is a cash-cow. In
 Rentals                   previous years, the museum was rented as a venue for the Sundance
                           Film Festival. Facility rentals can earn the museum between $50,000
                           and $100,000 for a week-long Sundance rental.
 Fees for:                 General Admission: Adults: $10.00; Seniors/Students/Military: $8.00;
 • General Admission       Children (7-17): $5.00
 • School Groups           School Programs are Free.
 • Programs                Programs include walking tours, which cost $5.00 per person, or $12.00
 • Facility Rentals        for a museum/tour combo ticket. Private tours are $15.00.
 • Other Events

 Number of Staff           4 Full Time Staff (Director, Education, Curatorial, and Archives).
                           1 Part Time Store manager
                           9 Chamber of Commerce staff work the front desk. They are on the
                           Chamber payroll, but the museum serves as the town’s visitor center.
 Number of Volunteers      200 Volunteers
 Total Expenses            (From 2014 990): $938,765
                           Annual occupancy expense: $10,000 to city to cover maintenance
                           expenses, as building is owned by the city.
 Total Revenue             (From 2014 990) : $1,164,837
 Revenue from:
 • Admissions              $149,426
 • Programs                $28,246
 • Facility Rentals        $115,225
 • Memberships             $87,238
 Facility Size             Building is about 12,000 square feet, but about 3,000 are reserved for
                           offices, library, and gift shop space. About 9,000 square feet are exhibit
                           space, some of which is a “teaser” exhibit that is available to the non-
                           paying public.




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                                        A-17

Source page 116

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                                 April 13, 2017



                                        Table A-4 (continued)
                                         Park City Museum
                                            Park City, UT
 Success Factors /             •   Museum renovation and expansion cost $8.9 million and opened in
 Lessons Learned                   October, 2009. The museum entered into an agreement with the
                                   city, where they raised money to expand and renovate the historic
                                   City Hall to house the museum, and pay $10,000 per year on a 100-
                                   year lease to the City.
                               •   City is unique in its demographics – there are about 5,000 year
                                   round residents and many other non-permanent residents. Many
                                   of the local population are wealthy and older, making for a good
                                   corps of volunteers, except that many of the volunteers are
                                   unreliable, because they travel frequently.
                               •   Popular winter and summer vacation destination, tourism is highly
                                   seasonal, with the Sundance Film Festival, in particular, drawing
                                   about 45,000 visitors to Park City over a ten-day period annually.
Source: Park City Museum; Interview with Sandra Morrison, Executive Director (February 1, 2017)

                                              Figure A-15
                                           Park City Museum
                                             Park City, UT




                Source: Park City Museum




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                                             A-18

Source page 117

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                            April 13, 2017



                                     Figure A-16
                    Park City Museum – Skier Subway Theater Exhibit
                                    Park City, UT




              Source: Park City Museum

                                     Figure A-17
                 Park City Museum – Mega Mine and Days of Ore Exhibits
                                     Park City, UT




              Source: Park City Museum



Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                        A-19

Source page 118

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                            April 13, 2017



                                       Table A-5
                                Museum of Durham History
                                      Durham, NC
 Name and Location         Museum of Durham History, Durham, North Carolina

 Attendance (Total)        9,130 visitors in 2014-2015 Fiscal Year. 8,874 attended off-site
                           exhibits. Total visitation increased 18 percent over preceding year.
 Number of Facility        Occasionally – not an earned revenue option. 3-4 times per year.
 Rentals                   Mostly relating to Duke University or small holiday parties. Not a huge
                           earned revenue stream.
 Fees for:                 No fees for programs
 Number of Staff           2 FT, 2 PT weekend managers, other staff are outsourced.
                           Organization is not sure that the museum have internal curatorial
                           expertise. Relationship with the community is the biggest assets.
                           Fundraising cannot be outsourced – lots of cultural capital, but not real
                           capital.
 Number of Volunteers      Over 135 volunteers donated 4,800 hours in FY 2014-2015.
 Total Expenses            $167,531
                           Fundraising:             $29,198
                           Operations:              $40,819
                           Programs and Exhibits: $97,514
 Total Revenue             $175,753
 Revenue from:             No Admission Fee
 • Admissions              Individual Donations: $69,392
 • Programs                Sponsorship:             $39,939
 • Facility Rentals        City/County Gov.         $32,500
 • Memberships             Foundations              $22,500
                           Businesses               $9,024
                           Other:                   $2,398
 Facility Size             1,200 Square Feet (old bus depot, familiar, lots of windows, lets light in,
                           lets Durham in)
                           Future goal: 5,000 Square Feet. Exploring alternative locations, hoping
                           to expand the building on the current site and improve accessibility.
                           (Worked with an architect for that space needs evaluation). Keeping it
                           small means they can keep being a museum without walls.




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                                         A-20

Source page 119

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                                               April 13, 2017



                                      Table A-5 (continued)
                                    Museum of Durham History
                                          Durham, NC
 Success Factors /           •     A community-driven museum, this organization was set into
 Lessons Learned                   motion when a 2004 Cultural Master Plan for the City/County of
                                   Durham rated a history museum as one of the community’s highest
                                   priorities. Lots of small parts of history, but not a single place to
                                   stitch it together.
                             •     80-year history of organizations and community groups wanting to
                                   form a history museum for Durham.
                             •     Business model: Goal to grow organically from community support.
                             •     The current museum facility is a 900-square foot historic bus depot.
                                   The organization was incorporated in 2008, and the first facility
                                   opened to the public in October 2013.
                             •     Inspiration: Levine Museum of the New South (Charlotte, NC).
                                   Unfortunately, most museums are larger, so they have more
                                   physical space for earned revenue.
                             •     Great people involved – “movers and shakers” from the community.
                                   Not all donor-class. More Boomers and professionals from Duke
                                   and other larger organizations. Goal – we want to be the best.
                             •     Museum Without Walls – hired by developers in the area to create
                                   exhibits in the lobbies of buildings. Small consulting or exhibit
                                   development efforts.
                             •     One exhibition annually in places outside the museum – one in the
                                   baseball stadium this past year. Big sponsors for those exhibits that
                                   help sustain operations.
                             •     Just because a city “deserves” a museum devoted to its nuanced
                                   history, doesn’t mean that the museum must be made. There are
                                   other interpretive options.
                             •     Before launching into the future, the organization needs to shore up
                                   community / public sector financial support; however, balancing
                                   that with the future vision.
                             •     Big challenge in location – on Main Street, but not easy to get to for
                                   foot traffic.
                             •     Important to make sure the museum is meaningful to the local
                                   audience, and they are all busy! The out-of-towners won’t have the
                                   same level of busy-ness or connection to the content. Keeping it
                                   small and easy makes it palatable for a busy local audience.
Source: Museum of Durham History




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                                           A-21

Source page 120

ConsultEcon, Inc.
Management & Economic Insight                                         April 13, 2017



                                      Figure A-18
                           Museum of Durham History – Exterior
                                      Durham, NC




               Source: Durham CVB

                                     Figure A-19
                      Museum of Durham History – Visitors to Museum
                                     Durham, NC




Source: Park City Museum




Paul Revere Heritage Site                                                     A-22